Skip to content

Same-day emergency tarping

(855) 741-ROOF
Dimensional Pro Construction
Roofing work in the Dallas-Fort Worth area

July 12, 2023

How to Choose the Right Roofing Material

There is no single best roofing material. The right one depends on your house, your budget and your plans. Answer these six questions and the choice usually narrows to one or two options.

Not sure what shape your roof is in?

Free inspection scheduled within 24 hours. Free, with photos you keep.

1. What is your budget, now and over time?

Architectural asphalt shingles cost the least up front and are the most common choice in North Texas. Metal and tile cost more to install but last longer. Think about the cost per year of service, not just the install price.

2. How long will you stay?

If you might sell within five to ten years, a quality architectural or impact-resistant shingle is usually the smart choice. If you plan to stay for decades, a longer-lasting material starts to make more financial sense.

3. How much hail does your house see?

In North Texas, the answer is a lot. Class 4 impact-resistant shingles cost more than standard shingles, but they hold up far better, and many Texas insurers offer a premium discount for them. Ask your agent what the discount would be before deciding.

4. Can your structure carry it?

Asphalt and metal are light. Clay tile, concrete tile and slate are heavy, and the framing has to be designed for that weight. Switching from shingles to tile often means structural work.

5. What style is the house?

  • Traditional and craftsman homes: architectural or designer shingles
  • Modern farmhouse: dark shingles, often with metal accents on porches
  • Mediterranean and Spanish: tile
  • Rustic or ranch: designer shingles that mimic shake, or metal
  • Look at samples outside, next to your brick and trim, in daylight.

    6. What does your HOA allow?

    Many North Texas neighborhoods restrict materials, colors or profiles. Check before you fall in love with anything, and get approval in writing before material is ordered.

    A quick comparison

  • Architectural asphalt: affordable, easy to repair, rated 25 to 30 years
  • Impact-resistant asphalt: similar look, much better against hail
  • Designer asphalt: heavy profiles that imitate slate or shake
  • Standing-seam metal: 40 years or more, handles wind well, higher cost
  • Tile: very long-lasting tile, heavy, higher cost
  • Help deciding

    We install shingles from GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, Atlas and IKO, and we bring physical samples to your house. Call (855) 741-ROOF.

    Get a free roof inspection

    No cost, no obligation, and a photo report you keep either way. If there is nothing wrong with your roof, we will tell you that.

    We answer or call back in under 15 minutes during business hours.

    Free inspection scheduled within 24 hours.

    Emergency tarping on site the same day.

    Prefer to talk to someone?(855) 741-ROOF

    Water coming in right now? We tarp same day.

    Want to pay monthly? See financing options.

    Preferred inspection window

    No obligation and no cost. We answer or call back in under 15 minutes during business hours. We never sell your information.

    Call NowFree Inspection